“All or Nothing” by O-Town
My go-to song for slow dancing in middle school was “All or Nothing” by O-Town. To me, it was about having a crush on someone and being unsure if they liked you back — which, hello, was the story of my life back then. I would always dance to it with my then-crush, John, and blush uncontrollably, wishing he would just tell me if it was all . . . or nothing at all!