Beyoncé as Eliza Schuyler
The moment we heard the first few verses of "Helpless," we could see Beyoncé singing this part. Beyoncé has already ventured into film roles with movies like Dreamgirls, and we could see her shining in this part. If Beyoncé wasn't interested, we'd cast Kelly Clarkson, who is also featured on The Hamilton Mixtape.
Standout song: "Helpless"