Bantam Bagels Hot Pretzel ($34/three dozen)
New Yorkers are lucky to have had access to Bantam Bagels since their beginning, and Starbucks locations nationwide carry the cream-cheese-stuffed bagel bites. But did you know you can buy Bantam Bagels in the freezer section? Our favorite flavor (and Oprah's!) is the Hot Pretzel Bagel With Cheddar Dijon Cream Cheese, which is so memorable that it's worth ordering online in bulk.