POPSUGAR Editors' Definitive Ranking of the 15 Weirdest Oreo Flavors

Caramel Apple Oreos are like the quintessential caramel apple lollipops in cookie form . . . or at least, that's what you'd expect. Instead, we found that the Oreos were oddly sour and too artificial for our liking. The combination of the salty cookie, the sweet caramel, and the green apple filling just doesn't work.